Brolly Calls for Resignation of DAERA Permanent Secretary Following Fivemiletown Admission

Nov 17, 2026

Aontú East Derry representative Gemma Brolly has called for the resignation of Katrina Godfrey Permanent Secretary of DAERA, following her admission to the Assembly’s AERA Committee that she accepted responsibility for the failures identified in the independent review of the Fivemiletown cattle cull.
Ms Brolly said: “The Permanent Secretary stood before the Agriculture Committee and stated, ‘If you are looking to know who is responsible, it’s me.’ Those were her own words. The question now facing Stormont is straightforward. If she accepts responsibility, why is she still in post?
The Aontú Deputy Leader continued: “This was not a simple administrative error. This was not a misplaced file or an uncrossed ‘t’. This was the slaughter of 51 animals in an operation that caused outrage across the farming community and deep distress among local residents.”
Ms Brolly said that the findings of the independent review painted a deeply concerning picture of failures within the Department: “The review, questionable as is may be, identified significant shortcomings in planning, governance, escalation procedures and communications. We heard admissions that senior oversight was not good enough, that crucial issues were not escalated appropriately and that insufficient consideration was given to the impact on the local community. These were not minor failings. They represented a catalogue of errors at the heart of government decision-making.”
Responding to comments from Katrina Godfrey warning against creating a “blame culture”, Ms Brolly said accountability should not be confused with scapegoating. “Nobody is calling for a blame culture. What people across our rural communities are calling for is fairness and accountability. There is a clear distinction between witch-hunting staff and holding senior leadership accountable for acknowledged failures. Accountability is not an attack on public servants. It is a basic principle of good governance.
Indeed, if what we are now witnessing is an attempt to position the Permanent Secretary as the fall guy for wider failings within the Department, that is unfortunate. But that does not change the principle involved.
Ms Brolly continued: “In any other walk of life, if a senior manager publicly accepted responsibility for failures of this scale, they would be held properly accountable and expected to leave their position. Why should it be any different at the highest levels of government? Why should a different standard apply at the top of the Civil Service than applies to ordinary workers, teachers, healthcare staff, farmers or private sector employees?”
Ms Brolly said public confidence can only be restored when those in positions of authority lead by example: “Leadership is not simply about accepting praise when things go right. Leadership means accepting consequences when things go wrong. The higher the office, the greater the responsibility. Public confidence is damaged when accountability appears to stop at the door of senior government offices. Those entrusted with leading government departments should be setting the standard for the rest of society, not operating under a different set of rules.”
Concluding, Ms Brolly said: “The Permanent Secretary has accepted responsibility. The review has documented serious failures. The farming community and the wider public deserve to see that accountability has meaning.
Responsibility cannot simply be a soundbite delivered before a committee that just disappears into the sunset. It must carry consequences. For confidence to be restored in DAERA and in public administration more widely, I believe Ms Godfrey must resign from her position as Permanent Secretary.”
0
0
Your Cart
Empty CartYour cart is emptyReturn to Shop
Secure Checkout
Fast Shipping
Easy Returns